KEEP VICTORIA FALLS WILD

KEEP VICTORIA FALLS WILD
Save Victoria Falls from over-development - click to visit site - www.keepvictoriafallswild.com
Showing posts with label overtourism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label overtourism. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 August 2026

Victoria Falls: An environment on the edge

(BBC World Service, 11 August 2026) 

The Victoria falls, on the border of Zambia and Zimbabwe, is considered one of the natural wonders of the world. But as Isa Jacobson reports, there is concern that development around the waterfall could threaten the delicate ecosystem and exacerbate conflict between humans and wildlife.


TheDocumentary Podcast Victoria Falls: An environment on the edge (28 mins), available to listen and download online on the BBC website.

The programme was broadcast in the UK on 11th August 2026 on BBC Radio 4 as part of the series 'Crossing Continents' series - Victoria Falls: Wilderness on the edge (available only in the UK).

Read more on the issues highlighted in the programme on the Keep Victoria Falls Wild webiste.


Thursday, 9 July 2026

Still Kicking the Can Down the Road... UNESCO World Heritage Committee Draft Decision text published

Keep Victoria Falls Wild, 9th July 2026 (revised 12th July 2026)

UNESCO World Heritage Committee Draft Decision text published ahead of 48th Session...

List of outstanding and unresolved issues grows as State Parties fail to respond to World Heritage Centre requests...

Committee yet again fails to address recent and proposed tourism developments within Site's 'No New Development' Zone...

Yet further delays to finalisation of new Joint Management Plan - five years and counting to develop draft a management plan covering a five year period.

UNESCO have released the draft papers and reports to be considered by the World Heritage Committee at its forthcoming 48th session, to be held at Busan, Republic of Korea over 19th-29th July 2026. The documents are available to download from the UNESCO website here.

Victoria Falls


The World Heritage Centre's overview and the Committee's draft Decision text relating to the Mosi-oa-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Site is published within document WHC/26/48.COM/7B.Add (UNESCO/World Heritage Centre, 2026), and presented below in full for ease of reference.

The Committee is due to consider its response to the latest State of Conservation report and draft Joint Management Plan for the World Heritage Site, submitted in December 2025. We previously reported on the many issues of concern within these documents in a Special Report in January this year (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, January 2026).

Mosi-oa-Tunya Resort Development (Zambia)

Under 'Current Conservation Issues' the text highlights lack of clarification of the status of mitigation measures, originally requested in 2024, relating to the Mosi-oa-Tunya Resort development in Zambia, constructed in 2021/2 "without fully meeting all the approval conditions set out in the Zambian Environmental Management Authority (ZEMA) Decision Letter" and currently managed as the Radisson Blu Mosi-oa-Tunya Resort.

"While it is reported that the completed construction of the Mosi-oa-Tunya Livingstone Resort Hotel does not adversely affect the OUV of the property, the 2022 Reactive Monitoring mission identified numerous shortfalls and non-compliance with the World Heritage status of the property, including differing interpretations of zoning terms. Given that the project has already been completed, and in light of the concerns raised by the mission and in previous Committee Decisions, the information provided by the State Party does not demonstrate whether the mitigation measures previously reported are being implemented to adequately address negative impacts on the property’s OUV. The development of a comprehensive Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP), as recommended in the 2022 reactive monitoring mission, and already mentioned in the report submitted by the States Parties in February 2024, is even more urgent to ensure that the mitigation and monitoring initiatives put in place also consider the visual integrity and cumulative effects of the project. In addition, the reported review of the 2007 Zonation Scheme should be expedited to clarify the inconsistencies and refine the associated permissible-use thresholds."

In summary this issue has not been progressed, by either the World Heritage Centre or the State Party, since the Committee's 2024 decision and request for mitigation measures. This development was pushed ahead without notification or disclosure to UNESCO during 2021, and continued despite requests from the World Heritage Centre to suspend development pending review of the proposals. A subsequent IUCN/UNESCO Reactive Monitoring Mission Report highlighted several significant issues of non-compliance with national planning approvals (UNESCO/World Heritage Centre, 2023a).

Baines Restaurant and Cataract Island Tours (Zimbabwe)

The text also notes no update has yet to be given in relation to the launch of tours to Cataract Island in 2022 and development of the Baines Restaurant over 2022/3. The Committee's belated draft reaction to these developments, following up on an unanswered request for further details from the World Heritage Centre on 14th March 2023 (UNESCO/World Heritage Centre, 2023b), is to merely state: 

"Finally, no update was provided regarding the third-party concerns related to permits for two commercial tourism developments in highly sensitive zones of the property, notably Cataract Island and its riverine rainforest on the Zimbabwean component, which remain of great concern, particularly given available online information indicating that they have already commenced operations."

So nothing has been progressed on this key issue, by either party, since the sending of a letter by the World Heritage Committee in March 2023. Tours to Cataract Island were launched in 2021 without notification or disclosure to UNESCO, despite a previous request from the World Heritage Committee for a full EIA disclosure in 2017 in specific reference to this proposal (World Heritage Committee, 2017).

The area of the Baines development has been protected against development since 1904 with the formation of the Victoria Falls Park. It was declared a National Monument in 1937 in recognition of its cultural heritage significance and protected as a National Park in 1952 in recognition of its conservation and environmental importance. In the mid-1970s it was part of an area declared 'permanently protected' against all new development under the Victoria Falls Outline Plan, before being designated as a World Heritage Site in 1989. Under the 2007 and 2016 joint management plans the area was declared part of the 'Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone' (HESZ) which prevents all new development. Yet despite all these protections the development was pushed ahead during 2022, without prior notification or disclosure to UNESCO and despite a legal challenge against its development in the Zimbabwean courts (still to be heard), and has been operational since 2023 (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, September 2023; June 2025; April 2026).


Victoria Falls protected area


The 1975 'Permanently Protected' Area, Victoria Falls

The EIA approval was granted on the basis of the false claim that the site of the development was within the 'Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone' (MESZ) and a permissible development - when it is in fact in the High Ecologically Sensitive Zone which prevents all new development. Even if it was in the MESZ it would still not be a permissible development. 

Critically, the 1975 'permanently protected' area has also not been fully disclosed to UNESCO within the joint management plans, leaving the World Heritage Committee in the dark over the protected area (Roberts, 2026).

Further Developments (Zimbabwe)

The text also indicates the World Heritage Centre sent the State Parties a letter in September 2024 requesting information relating to proposed tourism developments within the Site's 'no new development' zone (the 'Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone' or HESZ) - sadly not specified but believed to relate to the lease agreements, already signed with third parties, for the development of the proposed riverside 'tree lodges' and Kandahar Camp developments on the southern, Zimbabwean, side of the Falls. Not surprisingly, eighteen months later, the World Heritage Centre has not had any response to this request.

"In a letter dated 25 September 2024, the World Heritage Centre transmitted to the State Party of Zimbabwe, for comments, third-party information reporting the issuance of several commercial sites for tourism developments in contradiction to the existing JIMP within the property. No response has been received from the State Party at the time of writing this report."

So yet again, absolutely no progress on this issue since 2024.

Draft Decision Text

In its Draft Decision text the World Heritage Committee:

"4. Expresses serious concern that cumulative impacts from large-scale infrastructure and ever-increasing tourism development within the property, its buffer zone, and wider setting continue to pose a significant threat to the Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) of the property, a situation exacerbated, among other things, by the fact that several development projects, which the States Parties have indicated to be at the scoping stage, are currently underway, and invites the States Parties to provide further details on the reported development projects that are under consideration as soon as more information is available: ...

"6. Notes with regret that no update was provided regarding the third-party concerns related to permits for two commercial tourism developments in highly sensitive zones on the Zimbabwean component of the property, noting that information available online indicates that these developments have already commenced operation, expresses its deep concern about the potentially irreversible impacts of these projects on the integrity and the visual attributes of the property and urgently requests the States Parties to report on the monitoring and mitigation measures in place to ensure that the infrastructures do not negatively affect the OUV of the property;

"7. Also notes with regret that the construction of the Mosi-oa-Tunya Livingstone Resort Hotel proceeded without fully meeting approval conditions at the national level and following the Committee’s request to halt further activities until the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) had been submitted and reviewed, and reiterates its requests to the States Parties to implement the 2022 Reactive monitoring mission recommendation to develop a comprehensive Environmental and Social Management plan, which the States Parties indicated in their 2024 report was already being developed, ensuring that the mitigation measures put in place take into account the visual integrity and cumulative effects of the project and address its negative impacts on the property’s OUV;

"8. Also reiterates its request to the States Parties to ensure that any project located within the property, its buffer zone, and wider setting with potential impacts on the OUV is subject to assessment through ESIA or HIA in conformity with the Guidance and Toolkit for Impact Assessments in a World Heritage Context and submitted for review prior to any decision; "

Joint Management Plan

Regarding the draft Joint Management Plan for the site, the text raises several specific concerns to be addressed in a revised draft, to be submitted as part of an 'interim report' by 1st February 2027, but which will not presumably be considered by the Committee until mid-2028.

"13. Finally requests the States Parties to submit to the World Heritage Centre, by 1 February 2027, an interim report including a copy of the updated JIMP, taking into consideration the comments outlined above, and by 1 December 2027, an updated report on the State of Conservation of the property and the implementation of the above, for examination by the World Heritage Committee at its 50th session."

The new five-year Joint Management Plan for the Site was originally due for submission by end of June 2024, with UNESCO agreeing an extension until June 2025 to allow 'finalisation' of the plan (World Heritage Committee, 2024). The new plan was  subsequently submitted in December 2025, but with key sections missing (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, January 2026). It will now be at least mid-2028 before the 'final' version will be reviewed by the World Heritage Committee, meaning that it will have taken more than five years to develop a five year management plan.

Continued Failings

The State Party representatives on both sides of the river will no doubt yet again be patting each other on the back for successfully delaying any significant review of tourism developments at the Site by the Committee until 2028. The World Heritage Committee's current draft decision text actually undermines long-standing conservation protections preventing development. 

The failure of the State Parties to respond to previous Committee requests for further information relating to the Baines Restaurant and Cataract Island tours, and failure of the Committee to previously react to these developments, despite full particulars being supplied by 'third-parties', mean that these operations will have been operational for several years before the World Heritage Committee has even officially acknowledged their existence. The Draft Decision text response to the State Parties failure to notify the Committee in advance of this development, the flawed EIA report and subsequent EIA approvals is to merely request "the States Parties to report on the monitoring and mitigation measures in place to ensure that the infrastructures do not negatively affect the OUV of the property" is totally inadequate. 

The Draft Decision text as it currently stands is, considering the background the Baines Restaurant development and its location, a complete capitulation. The only mitigation measure which will ensure that the Baines Restaurant development does not negatively affect the OUV of the property, or more to the point infringe existing legal protections, is its total and absolute removal from the site. The Committee should, and indeed must, call for the upholding of these protections and for the development to be removed and the area fully restored to its natural aspect. Failure to comply should result in the Site being listed on the World Heritage Site List of Sites in Danger. 

The Committee's continued failure to fully address the issues relating to this and other tourism developments, including the proposed 'tree lodge' development, for which plans are well advanced (the development is reportedly to be managed under InterContinental Hotel Group's exclusive 'Six Senses' brand), at the current 48th Session risks legitimising inappropriate developments which threaten the future World Heritage status of the Site. Requesting mitigation measures on a completely illegitimate development, after it has been constructed without notification to UNESCO is not an acceptable compromise in this example, and is already proving totally ineffective in relation to the Mosi-oa-Tunya Resort development in Zambia. 

In failing to address and progress these issues the World Heritage Committee is rapidly making itself a significant part of the problem, and in turning a blind eye to these developments is actually facilitating in the degradation of this Site, raising serious questions and concerns over the whole 'World Heritage Site' system of governance and overview in relation to natural heritage sites - with the Victoria Falls rapidly becoming a prime case study example (Roberts, 2026).

- - -

Download the full draft text relating to Mosi-oa-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Site in pdf format here.

-  -  -

References

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (September 2023) Spotlight on Baines Restaurant. 11th September (revised). (pdf)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (June 2025) Special Report on the Riverine Fringe (pdf, 1.8mb)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (January 2026) Reaction and Response to 2025 State of Conservation Report and 2025-2030 Draft Joint Integrated Management Plan (pdf, 0.6mb)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (April 2026) Serious Concerns Over Management of Victoria Falls World Heritage Site (pdf, 1.3mb)

Roberts, P (2026) Paradise Lost? Conservation and Development of the Victoria Falls (1900-2025). Zambezi Book Company / CreateSpace Independent Publishing.

State Parties (2025) 2025 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya State of Conservation Report/Joint Integrated Management Plan (pdf download [18.9 mb], opens in a new window)

UNESCO/World Heritage Centre (2023a) Final Joint Mission Report Mosi-oa-Tunya, Victoria Falls (Zambia/ Zimbabwe) 9-13 February 2022 (pdf download [3.3 mb], opens in a new window)

UNESCO/World Heritage Centre (2023b) Conservation Issues, Analysis and Conclusions (45 COM 7B.10).

UNESCO/World Heritage Centre (2026) Item 7B of the Provisional Agenda: State of Conservation of properties inscribed on the of World Heritage List (WHC/26/48.COM/7B.Add).  Draft Decision text relating to the Mosi-oa-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Site.

World Heritage Committee (2017) Decisions Adopted 41COM 7B.22, point 6.

World Heritage Committee (2024) Decisions Adopted, 46COM 7B.60, point 5d.


Tuesday, 7 July 2026

Victoria Falls set for major transformation

 VICTORIA FALLS is set for a major tourism and investment boost following Cabinet’s approval of a strategic partnership that will pave the way for the development of a US$66,9 million integrated Tourism Park in the Masuwe Special Economic Zone (SEZ).

The project, which will be implemented through a partnership between the Mosi-oa-Tunya Development Company (MOTDC) and JR Goddard Contracting, is expected to transform a significant portion of the Masuwe SEZ into a modern tourism hub supported by world-class infrastructure.

Work is expected to begin around the under-construction Mosi-oa-Tunya Cricket Stadium before expanding across the wider tourism precinct. The development will provide critical infrastructure such as roads, water, sewerage systems, electricity and stormwater drainage to support investment within the 272-hectare Tourism Park located inside the 1 200-hectare Masuwe SEZ.

The project is one of the flagship tourism developments being pursued under President Mnangagwa’s development agenda, which identifies tourism as one of the key drivers of economic growth alongside mining, agriculture and manufacturing.

Since 2018, the Second Republic has prioritised infrastructure development, investment promotion and public-private partnerships as part of efforts to unlock the country’s tourism potential under the “Zimbabwe is Open for Business” policy.

Government has also adopted a cluster-based tourism strategy aimed at broadening the sector beyond traditional leisure travel into areas such as sports tourism, cultural and heritage tourism, meetings, incentives, conferences and exhibitions (MICE), medical and wellness tourism, and community-based tourism.

This approach is supported by the Tourism and Hospitality Industry Policy (2025-2030), launched by President Mnangagwa in August last year. The policy outlines a roadmap for growing the tourism sector through infrastructure development, sustainability, digital transformation, destination competitiveness and increased private sector participation.

President Mnangagwa has repeatedly stressed that tourism should be private sector-driven, community-owned and Government-facilitated, with investments such as the Masuwe Special Economic Zone expected to create jobs, attract foreign direct investment and contribute towards the attainment of Vision 2030.

Speaking during a tour of the Mosi-oa-Tunya Cricket Oval led by Vice-President Dr Kembo Mohadi last Wednesday, MOTDC board chairperson Mr Phineas Makombe said the project marked an important step towards establishing Victoria Falls as a world-class tourism destination.

“The Mosi-oa-Tunya Development Company is a State-owned enterprise under the Ministry of Tourism and Hospitality Industry with the mandate to plan, develop, manage and promote world-class tourism infrastructure in Zimbabwe’s premier tourism destination.

“In 2018, Government, through Statutory Instrument 18 of 2018, established the Masuwe Special Economic Zone to facilitate investment in tourism infrastructure and financial services over an area measuring approximately 1 200 hectares. Within this Special Economic Zone, the Mosi-oa-Tunya Development Company owns and manages 272 hectares earmarked for the development of an integrated Tourism Park,” he said.

Mr Makombe said the Mosi-oa-Tunya Cricket Oval was the anchor project within the broader master plan and would help attract additional investment into the area.

“Beyond this stadium, the master plan provides for the development of internationally branded hotels and resorts, a medical and wellness precinct, a championship golf estate, commercial and recreational facilities, a Culinary and

Hospitality School to be established in partnership with UN Tourism, as well as other tourism-supporting infrastructure designed to position Victoria Falls as Africa’s leading sustainable tourism destination,” he said.

Under the joint venture agreement, MOTDC will provide 271,5 hectares of land valued at US$25,6 million as equity-in-kind, while the JR Goddard Consortium will invest US$66,9 million towards infrastructure development.

The agreement gives MOTDC a 39 percent shareholding and the consortium a 61 percent stake, with a 25-year profit recoupment period.

Planned infrastructure works include the surfacing of eight kilometres of internal roads, the upgrading of nine kilometres of gravel roads, construction of a 13-kilometre water pipeline to serve the Special Economic Zone and surrounding communities, a package water treatment plant, sewer reticulation systems, effluent reuse storage ponds and a power substation.

Mr Makombe appealed for continued Government support to protect the integrity of the Special Economic Zone and safeguard its long-term investment potential.

“While significant progress has been made, we respectfully seek continued Government support in preserving the integrity of the Masuwe Special Economic Zone. The success of this development depends on maintaining the land for its intended purpose of high-value tourism and investment projects.

“It is therefore imperative that the Special Economic Zone retains its strategic character and is protected from incompatible developments that may undermine its long-term investment potential. Cabinet has already approved our strategic partnership with JR Goddard Contracting for the development of both on-site and off-site infrastructure.”

He said the phased rollout of infrastructure would ensure future developments within the Tourism Park are supported by services built to international standards.

Strategically located within the Kavango-Zambezi Transfrontier Conservation Area (KAZA TFCA), the Masuwe Special Economic Zone was established to attract investment into tourism infrastructure and financial services.

The integrated Tourism Park is expected to strengthen Zimbabwe’s tourism offering by providing high-quality facilities needed to support the continued growth of the industry.

Mr Makombe said the project demonstrates the Second Republic’s commitment to public-private partnerships and sustainable economic development.

“This project is a practical demonstration of the Second Republic’s commitment to public-private partnerships, investment promotion and sustainable economic development. It also complements the Ministry of Tourism and Hospitality Industry’s cluster-based tourism strategy, particularly in promoting sports tourism as a key pillar for attracting international visitors, creating employment and generating foreign currency,” he said.

Once completed, the development is expected to create employment opportunities, stimulate local economic activity and further position Victoria Falls as a leading tourism and investment destination in the region.

A major attraction within the development, the Mosi-oa-Tunya Cricket Stadium, is now more than 80 percent complete and is expected to host matches during the 2027 ICC Men’s Cricket World Cup. The event is anticipated to boost Zimbabwe’s international profile and drive increased investment in tourism, hospitality, transport and related infrastructure.

Source: Victoria Falls set for major transformation (06/07/26)

Saturday, 23 May 2026

Conservation concerns grow over new developments near Victoria Falls

 Plans for new developments near Victoria Falls have triggered growing concern among conservationists, tourism operators and environmental groups, with critics warning that unchecked construction could threaten one of Africa’s most iconic natural heritage sites.

According to Tourism Update, the dispute centres on several proposed tourism and infrastructure projects in and around the Victoria Falls area, a destination recognised globally for both its ecological significance and tourism value. Conservation advocates argue that increased development pressure could place strain on fragile ecosystems, wildlife corridors and the overall visitor experience.

Environmental groups have raised questions about the long-term sustainability of the projects, warning that poorly managed expansion risks undermining the very landscape that attracts travellers to the region. Some stakeholders are also concerned about the cumulative impact of multiple developments taking place simultaneously around the falls.

The area surrounding Victoria Falls supports a complex network of biodiversity and forms part of a broader conservation landscape shared by Zimbabwe and Zambia. Critics say any major construction near the site should be subject to stricter environmental oversight and greater public consultation.

Tourism operators remain divided. While some support new investment aimed at boosting regional tourism and economic growth, others fear overdevelopment could damage the destination’s international reputation. Concerns have also been raised about balancing conservation priorities with increasing demand for tourism infrastructure across southern Africa.

The debate highlights a broader challenge facing many of Africa’s leading tourism destinations: how to expand visitor economies without compromising sensitive natural environments. Sustainable tourism has become an increasingly important focus across the continent as destinations attempt to balance economic opportunity with environmental protection.

Victoria Falls remains one of Africa’s most visited attractions and is recognised for its exceptional natural beauty and ecological importance. Conservation organisations are now calling for transparent environmental assessments and stronger safeguards before further projects move ahead.

Source: Conservation concerns grow over new developments near Victoria Falls. Getaway Magazine (22 May 2026)

Monday, 23 December 2024

Victoria Falls City Council development 'masterplan' aims to annex conservation areas for development

(Keep Victoria Falls Wild, December 2024)

Victoria Falls City Council development 'masterplan' aims to annex conservation areas for development while claims of corruption raise concerns over process

In October 2024, following stakeholder consultations held in April (VFCC, April 2024), Victoria Falls City Council released details of the proposed new development 'masterplan' for the future expansion and growth of the urban settlement.

"The Victoria Falls City Council, hereby gives notice, in terms of subsection (2) of section 15 of the Regional, Town and Country Planning Act, Chapter 29: 12, as read with section 8 of the Regional, Town and Country Planning (Master and Local Plans) Regulations (RGN 248 of 1977), that the Draft Victoria Falls Master Plan has been Adopted and is now on public exhibition commencing 17th October 2024 and ending 16th December 2024." (VFCC, October 2024)

In November the Draft Plan and supporting documents and maps were made available to download online on the Council's website (VFCC, November 2024).

- Victoria Falls Master Plan - Draft Report of Study (April 2024)

- Victoria Falls Master Plan - Draft Written Statement (July 2024)

- Victoria Falls Master Plan - Main Map (Preferred Option)

- Victoria Falls Master Plan - Supporting Map (insert section)

In media reports Victoria Falls town planner, Ms Ntombizami Ncube, stated

"Our masterplan is now a public exhibition. We have already advertised two issues and we are waiting for the third issue... The masterplan will be on public exhibition for the next two months and we request all stakeholders to visit the Victoria Falls Town Planning offices or our website, all the documents are there for viewing. Issues that came out was the need to balance conservation of nature and development planning needs. We would want to expand, we don’t want to encroach into any restricted zones, especially the World Heritage Site, we are not touching." (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, November 2024)

The Draft Plan proposes to significantly expand the area controlled under the Council from just 22 square km to over 244 square km, including the Victoria Falls National Park and a section of the Zambezi National Park, the Masuwe Special Economic Zone, Nakavango Forest and Fuller Forest areas, all previously protected for conservation (see map below - click to download larger jpg file). The proposal includes the identification of some 12 square km of land protected under the Zambezi National Park for development as part of the Council controlled 'land grab'.

It is unclear why the expanded Council controlled area is proposed to cover the Victoria Falls National Park and a significant section of the Zambezi National Park, beyond that identified for development, and the supporting Plan documents make no reference to this significant expansion into National Park protected areas. These two National Parks are currently under the exclusive responsibility of the Zimbabwe National Parks and Wildlife Authority. It is also unclear why such a substantial area of Forestry controlled land to the south of the City is proposed to be included within the new expanded Council controlled area.

The plan offers no trade-off for the loss of the previously protected area of the Zambezi National Park to development expansion. We believe consideration should be given of returning the northern un-developed half of the existing Council controlled area (outlined in white, below) to National Park control, with the tourism concessions within this area also to be transferred to the management of the Park Authority. This area is an important wildlife corridor allowing access to the river above the Falls for elephant, buffalo and other species and was, until the mid-1970s protected as part of the greater Victoria Falls National Park. It is also essential to the integrity of the Victoria Falls World Heritage Site which covers the river corridor above and below the Falls. No new development, or expansion of existing developments, should be allowed in this area and the long term aim should be to return as much of this area to nature as possible.

The Plan presents no forecasts or modelling estimates of the projected growth in tourism capacity, which will see increasing peak-season tourist visitor pressures at the Victoria Falls World Heritage Site, while the strong seasonality of tourism to the Falls will see hotels and lodges empty for half the year and promised employment opportunities limited to short-term seasonal contracts.

Meanwhile the claims of corruption which surround Victoria Falls Town Clerk, Mr Ronnie Dube, and who has overseen the development of the Plan, raise serious doubts over the integrity of the Master Plan process (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, December 2024a). The apparent extension of his term of office beyond the maximum two four-year periods is un-procedural and raises yet further questions (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, June 2024), as does his reinstatement by a Government Minister following his suspension pending investigation into the significant and serious corruption claims (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, December 2024b).

Map showing proposed expansion of Victoria Falls City Council controlled area

Map showing proposed expansion of Victoria Falls City Council controlled area, annotated to highlight current area under Council control (white), the area proposed to be annexed from Zambezi National Park (red) and Masuwe Development Zone (purple). Click image for larger (un-annotated) jpg version - 5.37mb. The map clearly shows the Victoria Falls National Park as within proposed new Council Controlled area.


Map showing proposed enlarged section of central Victoria Falls City Council controlled area

Map showing proposed enlarged section of central Victoria Falls City Council controlled area (click image for larger jpg version - 1.15mb).

References

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (June 2024) Pushback as Victoria Falls council boss clings to power. 15th June.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (November 2024) Victoria Falls masterplan open to scrutiny.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (December 2024a) Corruption and abuse of office: Victoria Falls Town Clerk and 2024 CEO of the year suspended. 5th December.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (December 2024b) Government reverses ‘unprocedural suspension’ of Victoria Falls Town Clerk Ronnie Dube. 8th December.

Victoria Falls City Council (April 2024) City Master Plan: Shaping the Future of Victoria Falls.

Victoria Falls City Council (October 2024) Notice of Draft Master Plan on Public Exhibition.

Saturday, 9 November 2024

Victoria Falls to get two new upmarket hotels

 Zimbabwe's premier tourist destination, Victoria Falls, is set to see the construction of two luxury hotels, valued at a combined US$114.3 million, which will significantly boost the city's hospitality offerings. According to the Zimbabwe Investment and Development Agency (ZIDA), the new developments include a US$49 million four-star hotel and a US$65.3 million five-star resort, projects expected to attract both high-end tourists and investors.


The four-star hotel, part of the Mosi oa Tunya Hospitality Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT), will be the first to list on the Victoria Falls Stock Exchange (VFEX). The property will occupy a 5.61-hectare site, offering 180 rooms, including 60 executive suites, six twin suites, deluxe restaurants, a conference center, an infinity pool, and a wildlife watering hole. The construction is anticipated to begin by the end of this year and be completed by late 2026, ZIDA stated. The promoters have already secured 51% of the funding and are actively seeking the remaining US$24 million through equity and debt financing.

"Cresta Hotels will manage the property, which is projected to yield an internal rate of return (IRR) of 16.3%. The location, coupled with the REIT listing on VFEX, makes this an attractive investment with flexibility for investors to exit via VFEX REIT units," ZIDA noted in its prospectus.

The more expansive US$65.3 million Victoria Falls Resort & Spa will be constructed through a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) between Victoria Falls City and Lamcent Capital, a private Zimbabwean company. The resort will sit along the Zambezi River and offer 160 rooms in a recently constructed, five-star facility. With a 500-year concession period, the resort is poised to become a prominent player in the local tourism industry, rivalling Zambia's Radisson Blu in Livingstone.




To date, the project has secured US$6.8 million, with promoters seeking an additional US$56 million in capital. The Victoria Falls Resort & Spa has an IRR of 12.4%, a net present value (NPV) of US$13.6 million, and a payback period of 12 years, making it a compelling long-term investment, ZIDA added.

With Cabinet approval and asset status from the Insurance and Pensions Commission (IPEC), the project is set to appeal to pension funds, as investors will have a voice in the board's decision-making. The project also includes buyback assurances, with promoters offering to repurchase up to 25% of investors' equity upon exit.

Tourism, a priority growth sector in Zimbabwe, is expected to drive economic transformation under the National Tourism Recovery and Growth Strategy, which aims to expand the tourism economy to US$5 billion by 2025. The two hotels align with this strategy and are expected to help Victoria Falls meet the demand for luxury accommodations while enhancing Zimbabwe's status as a top-tier global tourism destination.


See Also

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (12th January 2023) Tourism sector attracts US$300m investment.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (25th May 2024) Multi-million-dollar hotel set for Vic Falls.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (10th October 2024) Another Cresta managed hotel for Vic Falls as UCPF seeks US$2.9m.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (11th October 2024) Unified Councils Pension Fund seeks US$3m for new hotel.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (9th November 2024) Victoria Falls to get two new upmarket hotels.

Read more on the Keep Victoria Falls Wild website.

Wednesday, 6 November 2024

Victoria Falls masterplan open to scrutiny

VICTORIA Falls City Council has completed the crafting of a new masterplan and opened it for scrutiny with priority being put on balancing conservation and infrastructure development.

The move buttresses President Mnangagwa’s launch of the “Call to Action — No Compromise to Service Delivery” blueprint, which provides guidelines for local authorities to ensure they provide efficient services that are in line with Vision 2030.

In the “Call to Action,” the President chairs a bi-annual review meeting to assess the performance of all local authorities in a move aimed at improving service delivery in towns and cities.

All local authorities are now obliged to adhere to a stipulated minimum threshold of service delivery before the approval of their budgets.
According to the blueprint, the quality of service provision by local authorities should be in line with an upper-middle-income economy.

Most local authorities have been operating without masterplans while those that have, were reportedly using outdated local plans.
Victoria Falls City Council also successfully finished drafting its 2025 budget, which was presented to the full council recently as the local authority strives to meet deadlines and targets set by the Government.

Speaking to journalists, Victoria Falls town planner, Ms Ntombizami Ncube, said the guiding document was now open to public scrutiny.

“Our masterplan is now a public exhibition. We have already advertised two issues and we are waiting for the third issue,” she said.

“We started last year and managed to meet the deadline of June 30. It was submitted to the Department of Spatial Planning for review and put on public exhibition.

“The masterplan will be on public exhibition for the next two months and we request all stakeholders to visit the Victoria Falls Town Planning offices or our website, all the documents are there for viewing.

“Issues that came out was the need to balance conservation of nature and development planning needs. We would want to expand, we don’t want to encroach into any restricted zones, especially the World Heritage Site, we are not touching,” she said.

Victoria Falls City is surrounded by Chamabondo National Park, Zambezi National Park and Victoria Falls National Park, which is home to the Mighty Victoria Falls, one of the natural wonders of the world.

The city was declared a Unesco World Heritage site and should be maintained in its pristine state with no disturbance to the natural environment, emphasising harmony between nature and humans.

Tourism, backed by wildlife and the environment is the cornerstone of Victoria Falls’ economy. Ms Ncube said after the display period and objections on the masterplan, a summary will be compiled and a report on the recommendations of the local authority prepared. These will be sent to the Ministry of Local Government, which will review the document for approval.

“The minister will approve and it will go on display for six weeks and during that period only issues that deal with issues of law will be dealt with. If it is felt that the document was done ultra vires then the issues will be dealt with,” said Ms Ncube.

Victoria Falls town clerk, Mr Ronnie Dube, said the local authority tried to do its processes timeously to maintain good governance.

“We are on time in terms of meeting the deadline. Technically, we can say our masterplan has been completed and this means we are a compliant local authority, particularly regarding the direction and instruction guidance, which we get from our parent ministry because when you look at the masterplan, it speaks to the ‘Call of Action’ and no compromise to service delivery as espoused by President Mnangagwa,” he said. — @ncubeleon

Source: Victoria Falls masterplan open to scrutiny (05/11/24)

Sunday, 6 August 2023

The significance and benefits of being on Unesco's World Heritage list

The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (Unesco) released its provisional agenda for the 2023 World Heritage Committee session taking place in September. The organization designates locations and structures around the world as World Heritage sites. It can also designate World Heritage sites as "in danger," signifying that they're threatened by any number of factors, including tourism, development and climate threats.

What are the designations?

Locations deemed World Heritage sites are of "outstanding universal value to humanity" and should be "protected for future generations to appreciate and enjoy," according to Unesco. The organization also lists World Heritage in danger, "designed to inform the international community of conditions" that "threaten the very characteristics for which a property was inscribed on the World Heritage list and to encourage corrective action."

The World Heritage list is a result of the Unesco Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage adopted in 1972. The treaty sets the guidelines for the consideration of a World Heritage site, and the countries that signed it agree to "conserve not only the World Heritage sites situated on its territory but also to protect its national heritage." These countries have access to a World Heritage fund that provides money annually to "assist states parties in identifying, preserving and promoting World Heritage sites."

Part of the treaty also includes stipulations for adding sites to the danger list. Unesco takes into account the ascertained and potential danger of sites and decides whether to add them to the list. If added, the World Heritage Committee can "allocate immediate assistance from the World Heritage Fund to the endangered property," and "the mere prospect of inscribing a site on this list often proves to be effective and can incite rapid conservation action."

How does designation impact a destination?

The effects of Unesco's designations are a debated topic. A site being added to the list can be a "kiss of death" and "all too often cures the disease by killing the patient," Italian journalist Marco D'Eramo wrote in 2014, coining the term Unescocide. Essentially, in designating a World Heritage site worthy of protection, the destination becomes a place of unsustainable levels of tourism. This was not accounted for in the original treaty, as Unesco "didn't have the scope of international tourism then," Mike Robinson, a professor of cultural heritage at Nottingham Trent University, told The New York Times.

For example, Italy has been struggling with overtourism, especially tourists vandalizing sites like the Roman Colosseum, which has been a Unesco World Heritage site since 1980. "Countries with Unesco World Heritage sites spend public funds on protective measures and archaeological ventures," stated Insider. "But vandalism forces those same host countries to spend money on security measures with that funding." It's also difficult for people who "work in cultural heritage and in tourism to find that right balance between protecting objects but not destroying the experience," Leila Amineddoleh, a lawyer specializing in cultural heritage, told Insider.

Venice, Italy, has been proposed to be added to the World Heritage in danger list, as overtourism and climate change have caused the city to remain "under serious threat," per the Times. The draft resolution from Unesco concludes that Italy has not made a "significant level of progress in addressing the persistent and complex issues related in particular to mass tourism, development projects and climate change."

In general, when places are listed, "when they clearly haven't got the right systems and policies and processes in place, there's always a problem," Susan Macdonald, the head of buildings and sites at the Getty Conservation Institute, told the Times.

Can it be helpful?

Being designated as a World Heritage site or being identified as a site in danger can raise awareness of threats that can harm the region. Highway construction was halted near Egypt's Pyramids of Giza, and a dam was stopped from being built above Victoria Falls on the border of Zambia and Zimbabwe, as these were sites seen as having cultural significance globally, per National Geographic. More recently, Australia's Great Barrier Reef was at risk of being placed on the endangered list, but the report opted not to add it to the list, citing "'significant progress being made on climate change, water quality and sustainable fishing — all putting the reef on a stronger and more sustainable path," Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said during a media briefing, Reuters reported.

There's also an incentive for developing nations to get destinations added to the World Heritage list to boost tourism. "The power of the Unesco brand can skyrocket a lesser-known destination to a different level," wrote CNN. Despite the threat of overtourism, a Unesco World Heritage designation can "bring much-needed money, support and global recognition to a deserving destination."

Source: The significance and benefits of being on Unesco's World Heritage list (05/08/2023)

 

Wednesday, 26 April 2023

A World Heritage Designation Can Be a Blessing, or a Curse

 To the north up the Kenyan coast is Lamu Town, its small streets humming with the sounds of chisels and hammers crafting Swahili doors, and donkeys carrying heavy loads of coral limestone. Locals and tourists jockey for space in the zigzagging alleys, with shops selling everything from silver jewelry to body products made with locally grown baobab.


Down the coast, in neighboring Tanzania, is Stone Town of Zanzibar, with its bustling fish market, where hauls of octopus and snapper come in daily from dhow boats, and countless Polish, English, Italian and Mandarin-speaking travelers shuffle through on tours that also take them to a memorial near the site of the city’s former slave market.

And between the two sits Old Town Mombasa and at its eastern tip, Fort Jesus, an imposing 16th-century structure built by the Portuguese, its multiple openings offering glorious views of the Indian Ocean, and gentle breezes that help stave off the coastal heat. But while these streets are busy, too, here in Old Town Mombasa, it’s mostly locals, unlike in the other two locales, where throngs of tourists flood the streets.

Lamu Old Town, Stone Town of Zanzibar and Fort Jesus are all UNESCO World Heritage sites, with Old Town Mombasa serving as a buffer zone, but Mombasa, unlike Lamu and Stone Town, is more of a stopover point en route to the Swahili Coast, an expanse of shoreline stretching from Somalia to Mozambique. So, any expectations locals might have had, of tourism arising from Fort Jesus becoming a World Heritage site, have not been met.

“We could be as good as Zanzibar, as good as Lamu for tourism,” said Peter Tolle, a local historian who guides tours in French, English and German. “Locals don’t want to talk about being a World Heritage site anymore and they feel shortchanged. Our houses are shabby, we have the money, but we cannot fix them.”

“We are trapped by their rules but there are no funds,” he continued, referring to UNESCO regulations around the changes that can and cannot be made at and near World Heritage sites.

Lamu Town, Stone Town and Fort Jesus exemplify the critiques that experts working in preservation and tourism level at UNESCO’s World Heritage List — a list of landmarks or natural areas that have been designated by the multilateral organization as having historical, scientific or cultural significance. These places include Machu Picchu, the historic center of Florence and the Taj Mahal.

They contend that being on the list can be a poisoned chalice, of either overtourism or undertourism. On one side, there is, as Mr. Tolle suggested, an expectation that being added to the list will somehow be a game changer for the community, bringing in money not only from UNESCO but also from tourism-focused investments and infrastructure projects. But Mike Robinson, professor of cultural heritage at Nottingham Trent University in England, noted in an interview that, in reality “there is no money and it has to rely on donors.”

In addition, the international agency has been blamed for what the Italian journalist Marco D’Eramo deemed UNESCOcide, when he wrote that being added to the list is a “kiss of death” and that it “all too often cures the disease by killing the patient”; that is, in acknowledging that a site is worth protecting, UNESCO can, itself, drive unsustainable levels of tourism.

Florence, Italy, where the Art for Tomorrow conference is taking place this week, became a World Heritage site in 1982, and it has long suffered from overtourism. It was estimated that in 2019, 15 million tourists — 20 times Florence’s population of 708,000 — visited the city that is home to the Uffizi Galleries and the Duomo di Firenze.

Aptly, the subject of UNESCO sites will be explored at the conference. The annual event was founded by The New York Times, and is now convened by the Democracy & Culture Foundation, with panels moderated by Times journalists.

That conversation will contribute to the debate over the heritage list, around what the benefits of being on it are, if in some places, the tourism the designation brings ruins a locale’s charm, while in other cases, inclusion on the list brings unrealistic hopes for greater change.

A History of Preservation

The idea for the UNESCO World Heritage list, which now has 1,157 sites, grew out of a project to rescue the monuments of Nubia, which include Abu Simbel, the site of two temples carved into a sandstone cliff in the Nubian Valley in Egypt in the 13th century B.C. In the 1950s, local engineers planned to build a dam along a portion of the Nile River to control flooding and generate electricity.

However, the dam would have flooded the valley and submerged hundreds of ancient monuments, so the Egyptian and Sudanese governments turned to UNESCO for help. The resulting project, during which Abu Simbel was moved, in pieces, up to a higher altitude, helped spark the 1972 Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage, which set up the heritage list.


Interestingly, tourism was mentioned only once in the document that arose from that convention, in relation to the threat it could pose to sites. “But, of course, we didn’t have the scope of international tourism then,” said Professor Robinson, who has done consulting for UNESCO on sustainable tourism, and who recognizes that tourism — in itself — doesn’t always have to be detrimental. “Time has moved on, we need to update that to say tourism is not just a threat, but it’s also a valuable opportunity.”

It is difficult to assess the direct economic impacts of becoming a World Heritage site. For example, Dubrovnik, Croatia, is on the list, but the city’s tourist invasion is very likely also related to the its role as a filming location for “Game of Thrones.”

However, a 2015 report by the United Kingdom National Commission for UNESCO discovered that Scottish UNESCO projects generated an estimated 10.8 million British pounds (or $13.4 million) from 2014 to 2015 through their connection with the heritage list.

That has meant that a number of countries, often in the developing world, want to get their sites on the list. Professor Robinson said that was partly because state parties “see it as a way of boosting tourism” and so “the motivation has shifted from site protection to site valorization.”

UNESCO Looks Ahead

There have been critiques that a change in who sits on the World Heritage Committee — a group of representatives from 21 countries who have final say over which sites are added to the list — has led to the list’s being politicized.

“You do get places moving forward for inscription that the advisory bodies have recommended not go forward because the care isn’t adequately in place,” said Susan MacDonald, head of buildings and sites at the Getty Conservation Institute. “When those places go on the list, when they clearly haven’t got the right systems and policies and processes in place, there’s always a problem.”

She added, however, that almost 50 percent of the heritage sites were in Europe and North America, so there was a feeling that the list needed to be more representative.

UNESCO suggests that representatives to the World Heritage Committee be experts in preservation and conservation, but leaves the ultimate selection up to the countries themselves. “So, you started to get this shift from a completely expert body to one that was sort of a mixture,” Ms. MacDonald said. “And when that happens, you get lobbying.”

What often is not well articulated to local communities is that when sites — which include both cultural sites, like the Vietnamese town of Hoi An, and natural sites, like Yellowstone National Park — go on the list, it is the obligation of local and national governments of those countries to take care of everything from maintaining and marketing the site to controlling the number of tourists who visit.

“Once a site is inscribed, it is first the responsibility of the government of the country where the site is located to put in place all measures to protect the site,” said Lazare Eloundou Assomo, the director of the UNESCO World Heritage Center, which maintains the list.

So, while UNESCO does help countries develop sustainable tourism practices and give advice, inclusion on the list doesn’t automatically mean solutions in terms of conservation or community development and investment.

“When you get something inscribed on the World Heritage List, it is not that the UNESCO police suddenly start coming in,” joked Joseph King, senior director at the office of the director general at the International Center for the Study of the Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, who in the 1980s and ’90s was a consultant for UNESCO. “You’d be surprised at how many people actually think that is the case like, ‘Why isn’t UNESCO stopping this from happening?’”

People like Mr. Tolle, the tour guide in Mombasa, find the whole process complicated and bureaucratic, and often misunderstand what becoming a site will mean for their communities. “They hear about it, and they understand it to be like the goose that laid the golden egg,” said Ms. MacDonald. “That sometimes doesn’t trickle down to them, unless governments have been careful to put in place systems and practices that empower local communities in the management of the place.”

 

Covid dramatized that point in places like Ethiopia’s lower Omo Valley, a region inscribed to the list in 1980. Before 2020, and the onset of the pandemic and the war in the north of the country, tiny remote villages like Dildi would get around 15 tourists a day, and the villages became dependent on the extra cash. But now, according to local Mursi chief Baradi Birabi, the visitors have all but dried up.

“With the money from tourists we could buy medicine for our people or our cattle,” he said, as one of the villagers tried to sell a clay lip plate to a lone Israeli tourist. “But now we have to sell the cattle, so we do hope tourists will come back.”

That’s a problem UNESCO is trying to work on, including a visitor flow management tool that will be extended to all sites by 2029, Peter DeBrine, who works on UNESCO’s sustainable tourism program, wrote in an email.

“Tourism can bring economic benefits to local communities and raise awareness about the importance of heritage preservation, but it can also have negative impacts on sites, such as overcrowding, societal changes, damage to fragile ecosystems and degradation of cultural monuments,” he added. “This is why UNESCO has strengthened its responses and tools in this area, and that it is committed to the development of sustainable tourism.”

Source: A World Heritage Designation Can Be a Blessing,or a Curse (New York Times, 25th April 2023)

Wednesday, 28 July 2021

Are World Heritage Site listings a blessing or a curse?

A UNESCO World Heritage Site listing carries a great deal of prestige, but can also outprice local residents and exacerbate inequalities

By Rina Chandran

BANGKOK, July 27 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - A beloved British city stripped of its hard-won World Heritage listing, an Australian treasure spared the blushes after it was left off an "in danger" list, and a Thai national park hoping to be third-time lucky despite its spotty human rights record.

Why are World Heritage Site listings so sought after, and why are they so controversial?

What is a world heritage listing?       

The United Nations' cultural agency UNESCO in 1972 noted that cultural and natural heritage are increasingly under threat of damage from decay, and from changing social and economic conditions.

Some of these sites are of "outstanding interest" to all mankind and must be preserved, it said. These sites can include monuments, dwellings, forests and mountains.

Currently, there are more than 1,100 heritage sites on the list, which is updated every two years.

A separate intangible cultural heritage list was created in 2003 for items such as dance, music and traditions.

How does a site get world heritage listing?

A country first does an inventory of its natural and cultural heritage sites and makes a tentative list.

The government then presents a nomination file to the World Heritage Centre for review. This is evaluated by two advisory bodies: the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) and the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

The World Heritage Committee makes the final decision.

What are the benefits of a World Heritage Site listing?

A listing carries a great deal of prestige, and benefits include "increased tourist visitation, increases in employment opportunities and income for local communities, and better management and protection of the place," according to the government of Australia, which has 20 World Heritage Sites.

Sites can also receive monetary assistance from the World Heritage Fund.

Is there a downside to a World Heritage Site listing?

Criticism has grown over the years, with researchers, conservationists and human rights activists saying that the process is marred by bureaucratic wrangling and underhand deals between the committee and governments.

The rush of tourists - including so-called WHS baggers -  can outprice local residents and uproot communities.

There is also an imbalance between wealthier and poorer nations, with the former having far more sites on the list.

Even the IUCN has said the programme is in need of "radical change if (it) is to remain an effective conservation tool."

Why the controversy this year?

Last week the World Heritage Committee stripped Liverpool of its listing because new buildings undermined the city's "authenticity and integrity," making it only the third site to be removed from the prestigious list.

Then, the Committee said it would not add the Great Barrier Reef to a list of sites that are "in danger", some due to climate change, following intensive lobbying by Australia.

Environmental groups criticised the move, and said Australia was not doing enough to protect the reef.

On Monday, the Committee added Thailand's Kaeng Krachan forest complex after having rejected the government's bids in 2016 and 2019.

The addition came despite an unusual appeal last week by U.N. human rights experts to their colleagues at UNESCO: defer the bid until indigenous Karen people who live in the forest have been consulted.

"Should the nomination as heritage status be approved it would perpetuate the denial of the Karen's right to remain on their traditional lands and carry out their traditional livelihood activities," they said in a statement.

Hundreds of indigenous Karen people have been evicted from the national park, and a listing can mean more rights violations, said Surapong Kongchanthuk, head of the Karen Studies and Development Centre.

"They are not opposed to the listing - but the communities have not been reassured of their access to the forest," he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

"They are concerned that a listing will mean more tourists, and no place in the forest for them," he said.

A spokesman for the forest department did not respond to requests for comment. 

This article was updated on July 27, 2021 to add approval of Thai forest complex as a World Heritage Site

(Reporting by Rina Chandran @rinachandran; Editing by Tom Finn. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit http://news.trust.org)

Source: Are World Heritage Site listings a blessing or a curse? (27/07/2021)